diff --git a/internal/backends/scrobblerlog/scrobblerlog.go b/internal/backends/scrobblerlog/scrobblerlog.go
index 19ed30b..7955c15 100644
--- a/internal/backends/scrobblerlog/scrobblerlog.go
+++ b/internal/backends/scrobblerlog/scrobblerlog.go
@@ -151,9 +151,12 @@ func (b *ScrobblerLogBackend) ExportListens(oldestTimestamp time.Time, results c
 	listens := make(models.ListensList, 0, len(b.log.Records))
 	client := strings.Split(b.log.Client, " ")[0]
 	for _, record := range b.log.Records {
-		listens = append(listens, recordToListen(record, client))
+		listen := recordToListen(record, client)
+		if listen.ListenedAt.After(oldestTimestamp) {
+			listens = append(listens, recordToListen(record, client))
+		}
 	}
-	sort.Sort(listens.NewerThan(oldestTimestamp))
+	sort.Sort(listens)
 	progress <- models.Progress{Total: int64(len(listens))}.Complete()
 	results <- models.ListensResult{Items: listens}
 }